Primo Pizza

Discover Primo Pizza in Ponte Vedra Beach for authentic NY-style pizza, large pies, garlic knots, chicken parm, stromboli, and more. Family-owned spot offering pizza by the slice and delicious subs—no masks required. Call us at +1 904-217-0203!

Welcome to Primo Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Primo Pizza
Primo Pizza
Primo Pizza
Primo Pizza

Primo Pizza invites you to experience the joy of New York-style pizza right here in Ponte Vedra Beach. Located conveniently at 10870 US-1, this family-owned pizzeria prides itself on serving delicious, authentic pies and hearty Italian fare. Slices of cheese pizza, massive garlic knots, and crispy stromboli await. No masks are required here—just the sound of happy diners chatting over their meals. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a family dinner, Primo Pizza offers a warm atmosphere and flavorful options for everyone.

Primo Pizza stands out for its wide selection of pizza offerings, featuring over 37 types of New York-style pizzas from classic cheese to hearty meat lovers. Sicilian-style options include the famous Grandma pizza, perfect for those who prefer a thicker slice. Savor traditional appetizers such as crunchy mozzarella sticks and garlic knots, which are a true crowd-pleaser. Big families will appreciate the generous portions, especially with 12 appetizers and 116 dishes in total to choose from—dine in or order by the slice. The inviting restaurant atmosphere complements Ponte Vedra Beach's vibrant community, allowing locals to connect over delicious food.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

10870 US-1 #114, Ponte Vedra Beach, FL 32081, United States

Phone

+1 904-217-0203

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Primo Pizza
Primo Pizza
Primo Pizza
Primo Pizza

Primo Pizza has carved its niche in the Ponte Vedra Beach dining scene as more than just a pizza joint. After opening its doors, it quickly became a local favorite for quality ingredients and generous portions. With a menu that features 12 appetizer options and various categories that delight every palate, families flock here for lunch and dinner.

The menu spans an impressive range of items. Dive into classic options like garlic knots and mozzarella sticks, perfect for sharing. The salads—thoughtfully presented—ensure a lighter meal option, while the pasta dishes are hearty and comforting. Customers often rave about the specialty strombolis that can be customized with a variety of fillings.

Each ingredient is selected with care. The dough is made fresh daily, ensuring that every pizza crust is perfectly baked for a crisp bite. The signature sauces amplify each dish, from the cheesiness of the mozzarella sticks to the robust flavors in the marinara served with pasta. The attention to detail reflects a commitment to quality that resonates with visitors and regulars alike.

In addition, Primo Pizza showcases community spirit, often supporting local events and engaging with nearby schools and businesses. This connection with Ponte Vedra Beach fosters a welcoming environment, accentuating the restaurant as a gathering spot for family, friends, and the community. Primo Pizza isn’t just a restaurant; it’s part of the fabric of Ponte Vedra Beach life.

Primo Pizza

Primo Pizza boasts an inviting exterior that perfectly matches its warm, welcoming vibe. The restaurant features a simple but charming facade with ample outdoor seating, allowing diners to enjoy their meals under the Florida sun. Inside, the pizzeria has a cozy atmosphere, embellished with subtle memorabilia hinting at its New York roots. The buzz of conversations and laughter fills the air, creating a lively dining experience.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Had an amazing meal at Primo Pizza! My two pizzas and garlic knots were out-of-this-world delicious, and the prices couldn't be better. The owners were so warm and welcoming, making our dine-in experience truly special. Can't wait to come back!

L
Linda D.

Very clean establishment. The owner took our order. You don't see that anymore. What a lovely, friendly guy. Subtle NY accent that made you feel like you were actually visiting NY. We had the buffalo chicken pizza....and it was delicious. You must stop by and try anything on the menu.

P
Pace2HomeGroup

This is the best pizza I have ever had since I moved to Florida. As a native from Brooklyn and then Staten Islander, this is the pizza that we all love from back home . The proprietors were extremely friendly and reminded me of my roots back in NY. This place is a must if you want NY Pizza .

G
Gino L.

If you're looking for quality real NY pizza, this is your place. This is tasty NY style pizza. The sauce and cheese dough and crust were absolute perfection. One thing I wish pizza places would offer is a spicy pizza. 2 pieces filled me up and my stomach is never ending as I come up on 6 months pregnant. 2 pieces also filled my husband up, too. He was surprised but happy about it since we were able to feed us and our 2 girls plus bring half a pie home. Really quality pizza and a laid back restaurant with space for families. I thought it was funny my husband wore all his Boston hoodie and patriot hat and we walked into an all loving NY sports covered wall. We bought 2 drinks and a 16 inch pepperoni and got out under $25 plus left overs

S
Sarah B.

Im about to rate Primo Pizza by Nocatee. Ponte Vedra St Aug. I had a taste last week and it had me questipn who the #1 was here in N. FL. I can smell the New York from here old guy on phone sounds like a guy from howard beach. #yankee #pizza Orderd cheese pie well done. Was there as it came out of oven. Ate it leas than 5 min. 8.5! Cooked perfect, slightly well. Only way to order it. Cheese sauce ingredients here bring me back to nyc. Thank you

Z
Zach A.

You really need to check them out! Great pizza and great people. I love their chicken parm and pizza. Everything I've ordered has been top knotch. The dough, ingredients, and rolls are definitely high quality! The people are really kind and professional. My order is always done when they say it will be ready for pick up. I'm so glad I go here often. I love this place!

M
Max D.